Mrs. Sarah Shutrop is the Director of Formation, Theology Department Chairperson, and moderator of the Freshman Class, C.A.R.E., Christian Service Board, and Respect Life. She received a B.A. degree in English and political science from Rutgers University and an M.A. degree in theology with a concentration in moral theology and systematic theology from the University of Notre Dame.

Mrs. Shutrop said she truly enjoys being part of the IHA community and especially loves "working with the girls, walking with them on their spiritual journey, and being able to challenge them to think about the Church in new ways."